Sustainable Forestry Network Sustainable Forestry Network
Home
Year 2010 Oregon Forest Restoration Initiative
Books
Videos
News
Forest Facts
Get Involved
Links
Resources
Contact Us

Chapter 4.3

Advantages and Limitations of Some Forest Vegetation Management Alternatives

  1. Prescribed fire - use of fire in controlled situation

    Advantages
    • natural part of forest
    • needed to maintain some plant communities
    • works well on steep slopes where access is difficult

    Disadvantages
    • can be difficult in hot, dry, or windy weather, on wet sites, or where fuel is insufficient
    • can cause soil erosion and nutrient loss, reduce soil organic matter, and decrease water quality
    • may encourage other undesirable plants to invade site
    • non-selective
    • provides only short-term control
    • major planning involved
    • risk of excape

  2. Mechanical cutting - tractors or skidders with cutting attachments

    Advantages
    • can combine with site preparation
    • less labor intensive than manual methods
    • can be used most of the year

    Disadvantages
    • can make weed problems worse if done improperly or at wrong time of year
    • can damage site by compacting the soil, causing erosion, removing the organic layer

  3. Manual cutting - hand-held equipment, may be powered

    Advantages
    • selective - can be used to cut individual stems
    • little effect on soil, site, or water
    • creates employment
    • socially acceptable

    Disadvantages
    • labor intensive
    • expensive
    • provides only short-term control
    • worker safety is an issue

  4. Mulches - material (plastic, wood chips, cardboard, newspaper) applied around the base of trees.

    Advantages
    • applied at time of planting
    • only affects area directly around planted trees
    • little effect on soil, site, or water
    • only alternative when grass control required
    • creates employment
    • socially acceptable

    Disadvantages
    • labor intensive
    • expensive
    • often requires maintenance
    • may not control shrubs
    • may reduce aesthetics of site

  5. Cover crops - seeding non-crop plants, often legumes or clover

    Advantages
    • erosion control
    • may improve soil nutrients
    • may provide forage for wildlife
    • socially acceptable

    Disadvantages
    • introducing non-native vegetation
    • may compete with trees
    • may increase rodent damage to crop
    • difficult to establish
    • wildlife habitat altered
    • seed may be expensive or difficult to obtain

  6. Grazing - livestock (sheep)

    Advantages
    • can generate revenue
    • socially acceptable

    Disadvantages
    • timing is critical
    • potential for damage to desired trees
    • restricted to certain types of sites or species
    • can be expensive
    • can damage riparian zones and reduce water quality
    • major planning involved
    • possible disease transmission to native wildlife

  7. Biological control - natural predators or plant pathogens, fungi, viruses, bacteria, insects

    Advantages
    • highly selective
    • natural part of the forest

    Disadvantages
    • registration process necessary
    • environmental effects unclear
    • may be too selective in some cases

  8. Herbicides - synthetic chemicals

    Advantages
    • relatively low financial cost
    • can treat large areas quickly
    • can be used selectively on ground

    Disadvantages
    • can only be applied at certain times of the year - restricted in forest
    • strong public opposition
    • often harmful to ecosystem


Table of Contents
Chapter 4 Intro/Chapter 4.1/Chapter 4.2/Chapter 4.3/
Chapter 4.4/Chapter 4.5

Copyright (c) 1997-98 OLIFE -- Oregonians for Labor Intensive Forest Economics.
All rights reserved.

Sustainable Forestry Network
454 Willamette St. -- Room 211 Eugene, OR 97401
phone: (541) 684-4850
email: forestry@efn.org

Home News Forest Facts Get Involved Links Site Map Contact Us
Copyright © Sustainable Forestry Network 2007